Skip to content

AWS ‐ ECS vs EKS

Jump to bottom
Full Stack edited this page Aug 19, 2025 · 5 revisions

ECS VS EKS

ECS (Elastic Container Service)

The deployment setup for ECS typically revolves around Task Definitions, Services, and potentially leveraging AWS Fargate for serverless container execution.

Steps:

  1. Containerize Your Application

    • Package your application code and dependencies into a Docker image.

  2. Push Image to ECR

  3. Create an ECS Cluster

    • Logical grouping of resources (EC2 instances or Fargate tasks) where your containers run.
    • Create via AWS Console, CLI, or IaC tools like CloudFormation or Terraform.

  4. Define a Task Definition

    • A JSON file describing:
      • Docker image to use
      • CPU & memory allocation
      • Networking configuration
      • IAM permissions

  5. Create a Service

    • Ensures a specified number of tasks (instances of your task definition) are running.
    • Handles scaling, rolling updates, and high availability.

  6. Configure Load Balancing

    • Integrate with Application Load Balancer (ALB) or Network Load Balancer (NLB).
    • Supports dynamic port mapping and path-based routing.

  7. Automate Deployments with CI/CD (Optional but Recommended)

    • Use AWS CodePipeline, Jenkins, or GitHub Actions.
    • Typical workflow:
      • Source Stage: Code changes committed to GitHub/AWS CodeCommit.
      • Build Stage: AWS CodeBuild builds Docker image, pushes to ECR.
      • Deploy Stage: AWS CodeDeploy deploys the image to ECS, updating the task definition.
      • Testing & Rollbacks: Automated tests & rollback strategies can be configured.

EKS (Elastic Kubernetes Service)

Deploying applications on EKS involves interacting with Kubernetes through tools like kubectl and Helm.

Steps:

  1. Set Up an EKS Cluster

    • Create a cluster with worker nodes using eksctl or AWS Console.
    • Specify Kubernetes version, region, and instance types.

  2. Configure Service Mesh (Optional)

    • Use tools like Istio for microservice communication, traffic routing, encryption, and monitoring.

  3. Define Kubernetes Resources with Helm

    • Package/manage resources (Deployments, Services, Ingress) using reusable Helm charts.

  4. Manage Traffic with AWS Load Balancer & Ingress

    • AWS Load Balancer Controller connects Kubernetes Ingress with AWS ALB/NLB.

  5. Automate Deployments with CI/CD

    • Integrate Jenkins, GitLab, or AWS CodePipeline.
    • Example workflow:
      • Build Docker images, push to ECR/Docker Hub.
      • Update Helm charts & trigger deployments to EKS.

  6. EKS Blueprints (Recommended for Complex Environments)

  7. Secure Access to EKS Cluster

    • Use AWS IAM for authentication.
    • Configure aws-auth ConfigMap to map IAM roles to Kubernetes RBAC.
    • Use private endpoints to restrict control plane access (Anvesh Muppeda).

  8. Implement Logging & Monitoring

    • Integrate with AWS CloudWatch, Prometheus, Grafana for metrics, alerts, and centralized logging (AWS re:Post).

Key Takeaways for Both ECS & EKS:

  • Containerization is Fundamental: Package your apps as Docker images.
  • Infrastructure as Code (IaC): Use tools like Terraform or CloudFormation for consistent infrastructure management.
  • CI/CD Pipelines are Crucial: Automate deployments for efficiency and reduced risk.
  • Monitoring & Logging: Robust setups provide insights into app health and performance.

Note: Specific implementation details vary by application requirements, team expertise, and environment complexity.

Cost Analysis & Comparison: ECS vs. EKS

Understanding the cost implications of ECS and EKS requires analyzing various factors and running a simulated comparison to make an informed decision for your specific use case.

Cost Drivers for ECS and EKS

1. Compute Resources

  • EC2 Instances:
    Both ECS and EKS can use Amazon EC2 instances to run containers.

    • Costs depend on instance type (e.g., m5.large, t3.medium), size, and pricing model (on-demand, reserved, or Spot Instances).
    • Spot Instances offer significant cost savings for fault-tolerant workloads.

  • AWS Fargate:
    Serverless compute engine; you pay for vCPU and memory consumed by containers.

    • More cost-effective for irregular/bursty workloads.
    • For stable workloads, EC2 instances may be cheaper (nops.io).

2. Control Plane Costs

  • ECS:
    No additional charges for the control plane; pay only for provisioned resources (EC2 or Fargate).
  • EKS:
    Fixed fee of $0.10/hour ($74/month) per cluster, regardless of worker nodes/apps (CloudZero).

3. Networking

  • Data transfer between Availability Zones/regions can accumulate in multi-AZ EKS deployments (DevZero).
  • Use VPC Endpoints to connect privately to services like S3, reducing network costs.
  • Load balancer charges (ALB/NLB) apply to both ECS and EKS, varying by data processed and Load Balancer Capacity Units (LCUs).

4. Storage

  • EBS: Persistent storage; costs vary by volume size, type, and I/O.
  • EFS: Shared file systems.
  • S3: For large data storage (DevZero).

5. Other Costs

  • Monitoring/logging (AWS CloudWatch, Prometheus, Grafana).
  • Licensing for third-party tools/add-ons (CloudKeeper).
  • Operational overhead and required expertise.

Cost Comparison Simulation

Scenario:
Run 10 microservices, each requiring 1 vCPU and 2 GiB memory, average utilization 50%.

1. ECS Cost Breakdown (Fargate)

  • Compute:
    10 tasks × (1 vCPU × $0.04048/hr + 2 GiB × $0.004445/GiB-hr) × 730 hr/month
    = $346.74/month
    (Assuming on-demand Fargate pricing in us-east-1; check AWS pricing for latest rates)

  • Control Plane:
    $0 (no additional charges)

  • Total ECS Costs:
    $346.74/month

2. EKS Cost Breakdown

  • Control Plane:
    $0.10/hr × 730 hr/month = $73/month

  • Worker Nodes (EC2):
    Example: 2 t3.medium (2 vCPU, 4 GiB RAM) instances for redundancy/autoscaling
    2 × (2 vCPU × $0.0210/hr + 4 GiB × $0.0042/GiB-hr) × 730 hr/month
    = $111.49/month
    (on-demand pricing in us-east-1; check AWS pricing)

  • Worker Nodes (Fargate):
    Compute cost similar to ECS Fargate: $346.74/month

  • Total EKS (EC2) Costs:
    $73 (control plane) + $111.49 (EC2) = $184.49/month

  • Total EKS (Fargate) Costs:
    $73 (control plane) + $346.74 (Fargate) = $419.74/month

Simulation Conclusion

  • Most cost-effective: ECS on Fargate
  • Next: EKS on EC2 instances
  • Most expensive: EKS with Fargate (in this simulation)

Important Considerations & Optimization

  • Scalability:
    For unpredictable spikes, Fargate (ECS/EKS) may be preferable despite higher base costs as it avoids over-provisioning (CloudZero).

  • Utilization:
    Efficient EC2 utilization can be more cost-effective than Fargate for consistent, high-demand workloads.

  • Optimization:

    • Use autoscaling (Cluster Autoscaler, Horizontal Pod Autoscaler)
    • Right-size instances
    • Schedule non-critical workloads for off-peak hours
    • Leverage Spot Instances or Savings Plans (DevZero)

  • Operational Overhead:
    ECS may have lower direct costs; EKS may incur higher operational overhead due to Kubernetes complexity.

  • Vendor Lock-in vs. Open Source:
    EKS (Kubernetes) offers greater portability if avoiding vendor lock-in is a priority (Densify).

Detailed Deployment Plan: ECS on Fargate vs EKS Microservice Deployments

1. ECS on Fargate Microservice Deployment

1.1. Prerequisites

  • AWS Account with required IAM permissions
  • Docker installed locally
  • AWS CLI configured
  • Source code for microservices

1.2. Containerization & Image Management

  1. Dockerize Each Microservice

    • Create a Dockerfile for each microservice.
    • Build images locally:
      docker build -t <service-name>:<tag> .

  2. Push Images to ECR

    • Create ECR repositories for each microservice.
    • Authenticate Docker to ECR:
      aws ecr get-login-password ...
    • Tag and push images:
      docker tag <image> <account>.dkr.ecr.<region>.amazonaws.com/<repo>:<tag> docker push <account>.dkr.ecr.<region>.amazonaws.com/<repo>:<tag>

1.3. ECS Cluster & Task Definitions

  1. Create ECS Cluster

    • Use AWS Console, CLI, or IaC (CloudFormation/Terraform).
    • Select Fargate launch type for serverless containers.

  2. Define Task Definitions

    • Specify container images, CPU/memory, environment variables, port mappings, IAM roles, logging.
    • Configure health checks and resource limits.

  3. Create ECS Services

    • One ECS Service per microservice.
    • Set desired count, deployment strategy (rolling updates), and networking mode (awsvpc).

1.4. Networking & Load Balancing

  • Create a VPC (if not already existing), with public/private subnets.
  • Create an Application Load Balancer (ALB).
  • Define target groups for each microservice.
  • Configure service discovery (if needed).
  • Use dynamic port mapping and path-based routing for microservices via ALB listeners and rules.

1.5. Automation & CI/CD

  • Set up a CI/CD pipeline (AWS CodePipeline, GitHub Actions, Jenkins):
    • Source Stage: Code repository triggers pipeline.
    • Build Stage: Build Docker images, run tests, push to ECR.
    • Deploy Stage: Update ECS task definition and service to use new image.
    • Enable blue/green deployments and rollbacks.

1.6. Scaling & Updates

  • Configure ECS Service Auto Scaling (CPU, memory, or custom CloudWatch metrics).
  • Use rolling updates for zero-downtime deployments.
  • Update task definitions for new releases.

1.7. Monitoring & Logging

  • Enable AWS CloudWatch logging for containers.
  • Set up CloudWatch Alarms for service metrics (CPU, memory, errors).
  • Use AWS X-Ray for distributed tracing (optional).

1.8. Security

  • Use IAM roles for ECS tasks (least privilege).
  • Use security groups for service/network isolation.
  • Store secrets/configs in AWS Secrets Manager or SSM Parameter Store.

2. EKS Microservice Deployment (Kubernetes)

2.1. Prerequisites

  • AWS Account, IAM permissions
  • kubectl, eksctl installed
  • Helm (recommended for resource management)
  • Source code for microservices

2.2. Cluster Setup

  • Create EKS cluster with eksctl or AWS Console.
  • Set up managed or self-managed node groups (EC2) or Fargate profiles for serverless pods.
  • Configure IAM roles for service accounts (IRSA).

2.3. Containerization & Image Management

  • Dockerize each microservice (same as ECS).
  • Push images to ECR (same process).

2.4. Kubernetes Resources

  1. Namespace Creation

    • Create namespaces for environment isolation (e.g., dev, prod).

  2. Helm Charts

    • Use Helm to templatize Deployments, Services, Ingress, ConfigMaps, Secrets.

  3. Deployments & Services

    • Define Kubernetes Deployments for each microservice.
    • Use Services (ClusterIP or LoadBalancer) to expose pods.

2.5. Networking & Ingress

  • Install AWS Load Balancer Controller for ALB integration.
  • Create Kubernetes Ingress resources for routing (host/path-based).
  • Use service mesh (e.g., Istio, Linkerd) for advanced traffic management (optional).

2.6. Automation & CI/CD

  • Implement CI/CD pipeline:
    • Source Stage: Code repo triggers pipeline.
    • Build Stage: Build images, run tests, push to ECR.
    • Deploy Stage: Update Helm chart values, run helm upgrade.
    • Enable canary/blue-green deployments via Helm or Kubernetes strategies.

2.7. Scaling & Updates

  • Use Horizontal Pod Autoscaler (HPA) based on CPU/memory/custom metrics.
  • Rolling updates are handled natively by Kubernetes Deployments.
  • Use Cluster Autoscaler for node scaling (if using EC2).

2.8. Monitoring & Logging

  • Install Prometheus & Grafana for metrics.
  • Use AWS CloudWatch Container Insights for logs and metrics.
  • Integrate distributed tracing (Jaeger, AWS X-Ray).

2.9. Security

  • Use IAM roles for service accounts (IRSA).
  • Network policies for pod isolation.
  • Store secrets in Kubernetes Secrets or integrate with AWS Secrets Manager.

3. Summary Table

Feature ECS on Fargate EKS (Kubernetes)
Cluster Setup Simple, fully managed More complex, granular control
Orchestration AWS native (ECS) Open-source (Kubernetes)
Automation AWS CodePipeline, Jenkins, GitHub Actions Jenkins, GitHub Actions, ArgoCD
Networking ALB/NLB, service discovery ALB/NLB, Ingress, service mesh
Scaling Service Auto Scaling HPA, Cluster Autoscaler
Monitoring CloudWatch, X-Ray CloudWatch, Prometheus, Grafana
Security IAM roles, SGs, Secrets Manager IRSA, Network Policies, Secrets
Updates Rolling, blue/green Rolling, canary, blue/green
Complexity Lower Higher
Portability AWS specific Multi-cloud, open source

Tip: Choose ECS on Fargate for simplicity and minimal operational overhead. Choose EKS for advanced orchestration, portability, and cloud-native flexibility.

Detailed Deployment Plan: ECS on Fargate vs EKS Microservice Deployments (with Samples)

1. ECS on Fargate Microservice Deployment

1.1. Sample Microservice Dockerfile

# Dockerfile for a simple Python Flask app
FROM python:3.10-slim
WORKDIR /app
COPY requirements.txt .
RUN pip install --no-cache-dir -r requirements.txt
COPY app.py .
EXPOSE 5000
CMD ["python", "app.py"]

requirements.txt

flask

app.py

from flask import Flask
app = Flask(__name__)

@app.route('/')
def hello():
    return "Hello from ECS Fargate!"

if __name__ == '__main__':
    app.run(host='0.0.0.0', port=5000)

1.2. Infrastructure as Code (Terraform) for ECS on Fargate

# main.tf
provider "aws" {
  region = "us-east-1"
}

resource "aws_ecr_repository" "sample" {
  name = "sample-flask-app"
}

resource "aws_ecs_cluster" "sample" {
  name = "sample-ecs-cluster"
}

resource "aws_ecs_task_definition" "sample" {
  family                   = "sample-flask-task"
  network_mode             = "awsvpc"
  requires_compatibilities = ["FARGATE"]
  cpu                      = "256"
  memory                   = "512"
  execution_role_arn       = aws_iam_role.ecs_task_execution_role.arn

  container_definitions = jsonencode([
    {
      name      = "flask-app"
      image     = "${aws_ecr_repository.sample.repository_url}:latest"
      cpu       = 256
      memory    = 512
      essential = true
      portMappings = [
        {
          containerPort = 5000
          hostPort      = 5000
          protocol      = "tcp"
        }
      ]
      logConfiguration = {
        logDriver = "awslogs"
        options = {
          awslogs-group         = "/ecs/sample-flask-app"
          awslogs-region        = "us-east-1"
          awslogs-stream-prefix = "ecs"
        }
      }
    }
  ])
}

resource "aws_iam_role" "ecs_task_execution_role" {
  name = "ecsTaskExecutionRole"

  assume_role_policy = jsonencode({
    Version = "2012-10-17"
    Statement = [{
      Effect = "Allow"
      Principal = {
        Service = "ecs-tasks.amazonaws.com"
      }
      Action = "sts:AssumeRole"
    }]
  })
}

resource "aws_iam_role_policy_attachment" "ecs_task_execution_role_policy" {
  role       = aws_iam_role.ecs_task_execution_role.name
  policy_arn = "arn:aws:iam::aws:policy/service-role/AmazonECSTaskExecutionRolePolicy"
}

resource "aws_ecs_service" "sample" {
  name            = "sample-flask-service"
  cluster         = aws_ecs_cluster.sample.id
  task_definition = aws_ecs_task_definition.sample.arn
  desired_count   = 2
  launch_type     = "FARGATE"
  network_configuration {
    subnets         = ["<your-subnet-id>"]
    security_groups = ["<your-security-group-id>"]
    assign_public_ip = true
  }
}

Replace <your-subnet-id> and <your-security-group-id> with your actual VPC subnet and security group IDs.

1.3. ECS Deployment Steps (Summary)

  1. Build & push Docker image to ECR.
  2. Deploy infrastructure using Terraform.
  3. Update ECS Service to use new image (via CI/CD).

2. EKS Microservice Deployment

2.1. Sample Kubernetes Manifest (Deployment & Service)

# flask-deployment.yaml
apiVersion: apps/v1
kind: Deployment
metadata:
  name: flask-app
  labels:
    app: flask-app
spec:
  replicas: 2
  selector:
    matchLabels:
      app: flask-app
  template:
    metadata:
      labels:
        app: flask-app
    spec:
      containers:
      - name: flask-app
        image: <your-aws-account-id>.dkr.ecr.<region>.amazonaws.com/sample-flask-app:latest
        ports:
        - containerPort: 5000
        env:
        - name: FLASK_ENV
          value: production
# flask-service.yaml
apiVersion: v1
kind: Service
metadata:
  name: flask-service
spec:
  type: LoadBalancer
  selector:
    app: flask-app
  ports:
    - protocol: TCP
      port: 80
      targetPort: 5000

2.2. Infrastructure as Code (Terraform) for EKS Cluster (Basic)

# eks-cluster.tf
provider "aws" {
  region = "us-east-1"
}

module "eks" {
  source          = "terraform-aws-modules/eks/aws"
  cluster_name    = "sample-eks-cluster"
  cluster_version = "1.27"
  subnet_ids      = ["<your-subnet-id-1>", "<your-subnet-id-2>"]
  vpc_id          = "<your-vpc-id>"
  node_groups = {
    eks_nodes = {
      desired_capacity = 2
      max_capacity     = 4
      min_capacity     = 1
      instance_types   = ["t3.medium"]
    }
  }
}

Replace <your-subnet-id-1>, <your-subnet-id-2>, and <your-vpc-id> with your actual values.

2.3. EKS Deployment Steps (Summary)

  1. Build & push Docker image to ECR.
  2. Create EKS cluster and node group using Terraform.
  3. Apply Kubernetes manifests (kubectl apply -f flask-deployment.yaml, kubectl apply -f flask-service.yaml).
  4. Update deployment for new versions via CI/CD (e.g., Helm, Kustomize).

3. Summary Table

Feature ECS on Fargate EKS (Kubernetes)
Container Sample See Dockerfile above See Dockerfile above
IaC Example Terraform (ECS, ECR, Service, IAM) Terraform (EKS, Node Group, IAM)
Deployment Script ECS Task Definition/Service Kubernetes Deployment/Service YAML
Automation CI/CD for image build & ECS update CI/CD for image build & kubectl/Helm
Scaling ECS Service Auto Scaling Kubernetes HPA/Cluster Autoscaler
Networking ALB, awsvpc networking Ingress, LoadBalancer Service
Monitoring CloudWatch, X-Ray Prometheus, Grafana, CloudWatch

Tip: Use these samples as a starting point and adapt them to your specific microservices and AWS configuration.

Clone this wiki locally