Skip to content

Commit 51df2ad

Browse files
authored
Merge pull request #26 from pautva/danny-review
Review of Case Studies
2 parents b5f2385 + 891b517 commit 51df2ad

File tree

5 files changed

+23
-27
lines changed

5 files changed

+23
-27
lines changed

src/content/case-studies/geospatial-data-portals.md

Lines changed: 6 additions & 10 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
22
title: Designing Geospatial Data Portals
33
publishDate: 2024-07-09 00:00:00
44
img: /co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/covers/cs-cover-12.png
5-
img_alt: Soft pink and baby blue water ripples together in a subtle texture.
5+
img_alt: Black and grey water ripples together in a subtle texture.
66
description: |
77
We researched geospatial data users and designed guidelines to create user-friendly portals that make data easy to find and use for better decision-making.
88
tags:
@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ We also created 6 user archetypes to summarise the user research findings. Those
3939
* Non-geo data engineer
4040

4141
![Geospatial data portal illustration](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/geospatial/Persona-Investigator.png)
42-
*Investigator Archetype*
42+
*Investigator user archetype example*
4343

4444
### User Journeys
4545

@@ -65,21 +65,17 @@ The broad stages of the journey for discovering spatial data are quite similar f
6565

6666
The planning or problem space exploration stage usually doesn’t involve data portal use yet. In this stage some people might be proactively seeking new data challenges, some might be given specific data tasks to solve.
6767

68-
In the wide search stage people usually rely on search engines or colleagues to get a better understanding of the available data landscape. They might find out that the data they are looking for exists on multiple sources, so they must find a way to identify which one of them is more trustworthy and better suited for their challenge.
68+
In the wide search stage, people usually rely on search engines or colleagues to get a better understanding of the available data landscape. They might find out that the data they are looking for exists on multiple sources, so they must find a way to identify which one of them is more trustworthy and better suited for their challenge.
6969

7070
![Geospatial data portal illustration](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/geospatial/ux-formula.png)
7171
*Good UX formula*
7272

7373
Deep search stage is the place where people start using data portals in greater depth. They would identify the potential data portals that could hold the data they are looking for and they would want to narrow down the search. Data experts might spend a bit more time in the deep search stage to ensure that the data they found is the one they need, since they might not have the domain knowledge of that specific field.
7474

75-
The next stage – data evaluation and use – might also be done with the help of data portals. Users might want to examine the possible datasets to ensure that they have the appropriate license and meet their other requirements. There might be some extra steps of registering, purchasing or providing other details before data can be accessed. Many people mentioned that if these additional steps are too tedious it could discourage them from using the data portal or the data itself. They would also like, if possible, to visualise data in an appropriate format for its type and possibly preview a smaller sample of the whole dataset to avoid downloading large files or purchasing the wrong datasets.
75+
The next stage – data evaluation and use – might also be done with the help of data portals. Users might want to examine the possible datasets to ensure that they have the appropriate license and meet their other requirements. There might be some extra steps of registering, purchasing, or providing other details before data can be accessed. Many people mentioned that if these additional steps are too tedious it could discourage them from using the data portal or the data itself. They would also like, if possible, to visualise data in an appropriate format for its type and possibly preview a smaller sample of the whole dataset to avoid downloading large files or purchasing the wrong datasets.
7676

7777
## Data Discoverability 3
7878

79-
During the DD3 project, we collaborated with Ordnance Survey’s UX team to develop design guidelines, recommendations, and wireframes specifically for geospatial portal developers and designers.
79+
During the Data Discoverability 3 (DD3) project, we collaborated with Ordnance Survey’s UX team to develop design guidelines, recommendations, and wireframes specifically for geospatial portal developers and designers.
8080

81-
The recommendations are derived from user research findings from previous workstreams. Carl Watson has published a blog post detailing this work:
82-
83-
## Links
84-
85-
* [The secret to great geospatial data portals: start with the user](https://geospatialcommission.blog.gov.uk/2021/09/10/the-secret-to-great-geospatial-data-portals-start-with-the-user/)
81+
The recommendations are derived from user research findings from previous workstreams. Carl Watson has published a blog post detailing this work titled ["The secret to great geospatial data portals: start with the user"](https://geospatialcommission.blog.gov.uk/2021/09/10/the-secret-to-great-geospatial-data-portals-start-with-the-user/).

src/content/case-studies/inhfl.md

Lines changed: 6 additions & 6 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -16,13 +16,13 @@ organisation: BGS
1616

1717
> We took a leading role in developing a platform to simplify global hazard monitoring. We designed the initial prototype and conducted a user testing phase with stakeholders from various science agencies.
1818
19-
![Image](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/inhfl/sing-in.png)
20-
*INHFL Login Page*
19+
![Image](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/inhfl/sign-in.png)
20+
*INHFL prototype Login Page*
2121

2222
We created this document to share best practices and address common challenges in user research, development, engagement, and the integration of scientific knowledge, empowering the creation of effective DSTs that maximise their impact.
2323

2424
![Image](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/inhfl/view-data.png)
25-
*INHFL Events Page*
25+
*INHFL prototype Events Page*
2626

2727
### Methods and Tools Used
2828

@@ -31,7 +31,7 @@ We created this document to share best practices and address common challenges i
3131
* **User Testing**: A combination of in-person and remote user testing sessions, facilitated by the Useberry platform, allowed us to
3232

3333
![Image](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/inhfl/home.png)
34-
*INHFL Home Page*
34+
*INHFL prototype Home Page*
3535

3636
### Lessons Learned
3737

@@ -40,8 +40,8 @@ Overall, users find the prototype promising, valuing its design and potential. H
4040
This early prototyping and user feedback process will significantly save development time by answering critical questions upfront. The early prototyping and user feedback process will significantly save development time by answering critical questions upfront.
4141

4242
![Image](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/inhfl/headlines.png)
43-
*INHFL Headlines Page*
43+
*INHFL prototype Headlines Page*
4444

4545
## Links
4646

47-
* [INHFL Figma Prototype](https://www.figma.com/proto/SszgfI11TuW4Td3Bhe5ikw/IFL-Back-End-Prototype?page-id=&node-id=2503-2968&viewport=-288%2C1264%2C0.21&t=0HPvj9oyKuJZNF95-1&scaling=min-zoom&content-scaling=fixed&starting-point-node-id=2503%3A2968)
47+
* [INHFL Figma Interactive Prototype](https://www.figma.com/proto/SszgfI11TuW4Td3Bhe5ikw/IFL-Back-End-Prototype?page-id=&node-id=2503-2968&viewport=-288%2C1264%2C0.21&t=0HPvj9oyKuJZNF95-1&scaling=min-zoom&content-scaling=fixed&starting-point-node-id=2503%3A2968)

src/content/case-studies/personas-land-insight.md

Lines changed: 2 additions & 2 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -24,9 +24,9 @@ organisation: BGS
2424
### Persona Inspiration
2525

2626
* [Designing for Digital Twins](https://towardsdatascience.com/designing-for-digital-twins-e2b3e07a5d1e)
27-
* [Digital twins of the natural environment](https://reader.elsevier.com/reader/sd/pii/S266638992100221X?token=3F39E83900E36643E1F8C36907BAEE470CF9B3A81EB170AFA1D9FA22D03917154BE9E55C193D0C44EAF5EE430B466AC3&originRegion=eu-west-1&originCreation=20220408124400)
27+
* [Digital twins of the natural environment](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.patter.2021.100359)
2828
* [Towards Environmental Digital Twins in Azure with Dask and Pangeo](https://towardsdatascience.com/towards-environmental-digital-twins-in-azure-with-dask-and-pangeo-71d35414ec58)
29-
* [How ‘digital twins’ can model future effects of climate change](https://www.greenbiz.com/article/how-digital-twins-can-model-future-effects-climate-change)
29+
* [How ‘digital twins’ can model future effects of climate change](https://trellis.net/article/how-digital-twins-can-model-future-effects-climate-change/)
3030

3131
### Personas for Land Insight
3232

src/content/case-studies/ventura-vdr.md

Lines changed: 9 additions & 9 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ organisation: BGS
1919
> Our challenge in this project was to prototype a decision support tool which would enable local government, the local community and other relevant partners such as regulators and water utility companies to collaboratively plan and evaluate the environmental sustainability of urban growth planning scenarios using co-designed water neutrality indicators.
2020
2121
![Image](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/vdr/vdr-screenshots.png)
22-
*VDR tool will allow users to explore business as usual scenario, create new scenarios and view/edit model settings.*
22+
*The Virtual Decision Room (VDR) tool will allow users to explore business as usual scenario, create new scenarios and view/edit model settings.*
2323

2424
## Approach
2525

@@ -44,7 +44,7 @@ We also reviewed literature on the best practices for creating decision support
4444
* Gain insight into the nature of the planning object
4545
* Learn about other stakeholders
4646
* Increase collaboration among stakeholders
47-
* Share information and knowledge among various stakeholder better
47+
* Share information and knowledge among various stakeholders better
4848
* Find agreement on key problems and best solutions
4949
* Perform key tasks more efficiently
5050
* Make better informed plans or decisions
@@ -55,24 +55,24 @@ We also identified key goals of each user, which helped us prioritise product fe
5555

5656
#### The key users and their goals were:
5757

58-
* **Greater Manchester Combined Authority** - Explore VDR to inform the setting of rules needed to reach 2050 goal on managing flood risk
59-
* **United Utilities** - Explore VDR to inform the setting of rules needed to reach 2050 goal on surface water to sewer standards
60-
* **Strategic town planners** - Explore VDR together with United Utilities and Environment Agency to develop a collaborative plan for reaching 2050 growth targets in a sustainable way
58+
* **Greater Manchester Combined Authority**: explore VDR to inform the setting of rules needed to reach 2050 goal on managing flood risk
59+
* **United Utilities**: explore VDR to inform the setting of rules needed to reach 2050 goal on surface water to sewer standards
60+
* **Strategic town planners**: explore VDR together with United Utilities and Environment Agency to develop a collaborative plan for reaching 2050 growth targets in a sustainable way
6161

6262
![Image](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/vdr/vdr-home.jpg)
63-
*VDR tool will allow users to explore business as usual scenario, create new scenarios and view/edit model settings.*
63+
*The VDR tool will allow users to explore business as usual scenario, create new scenarios and view/edit model settings.*
6464

6565
## Impact
6666

6767
Involving users in the early stages of the product development had a number of positive impacts such as:
6868

69-
1. Better understanding of user needs: user research helped us identify the needs and frustrations of ‘trilateral’ group who would be using this Decision Support tool.
69+
1. Better understanding of user needs: user research helped us identify the needs and frustrations of a ‘trilateral’ group who would be using this Decision Support tool.
7070
2. Increased stakeholder buy-in: if the stakeholders feel that their concerns, needs and frustrations are taken into consideration, they are more likely to provide more feedback and answer questions that might arise throughout the project.
7171
3. Iterate and validate designs: testing and validating designs early on with the users increased the chance of getting the design right and saved time and cost later at the development stage.
7272

7373
This project is still in early stages of development. Further testing of the working version will allow us to understand the users and the context in which this tool would be used even better.
7474

75-
If we are successful and can create an effective decision support tool for evidence-led water neutral place making, it can have a number of positive impacts:
75+
If we are successful and can create an effective decision support tool for evidence-led water neutral place making, it could have a number of positive impacts:
7676

7777
* Improved water management
7878
* Reduced water consumption
@@ -83,7 +83,7 @@ If we are successful and can create an effective decision support tool for evide
8383
If this proves to be a successful tool, it could also be applied to other regions besides Greater Manchester.
8484

8585
![Image](/co-creation-toolkit/assets/case-studies/vdr/vdr-screenshot.jpg)
86-
*VDR tool will allow users to explore business as usual scenario, create new scenarios and view/edit model settings.*
86+
*The VDR tool will allow users to explore business as usual scenario, create new scenarios and view/edit model settings.*
8787

8888
## Lessons learned
8989

File renamed without changes.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)