Skip to content

PORTN-3057 Add new guide for mapping HiBob users to Port accounts #2572

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Open
wants to merge 8 commits into
base: main
Choose a base branch
from

Conversation

kodjomiles
Copy link
Contributor

Description

Added a new guide to ingest Hibob users and map them to existing port accounts

Added docs pages

Please also include the path for the added docs

  • Ingest and Map Hibob users to Port accounts (/guides/all/map-hibob-users-to-port-accounts)

@kodjomiles kodjomiles requested a review from hadar-co July 23, 2025 00:08
@kodjomiles kodjomiles self-assigned this Jul 23, 2025
Copy link

Copy link

This pull request is automatically being deployed by Amplify Hosting (learn more).

Access this pull request here: https://pr-2572.d2ngvl90zqbob8.amplifyapp.com

Copy link

claude bot commented Aug 7, 2025

Claude finished @kodjomiles's task —— View job


PR Review: HiBob Users to Port Accounts Guide

I've completed a thorough review of the PR changes according to the CONTRIBUTING.md guidelines. Here's my detailed analysis:

Todo List:

  • Read CONTRIBUTING.md to understand review criteria
  • Review the new guide file (map-hibob-users-to-port-accounts.md)
  • Review the const.js modifications
  • Check for compliance with documentation standards
  • Provide detailed feedback

Overall Assessment

This PR successfully adds a comprehensive guide for integrating HiBob users with Port accounts. The implementation follows most documentation standards with some areas for improvement.

📋 Detailed Review

Content Quality & Structure

  • Clear objective: Well-defined purpose and expected outcomes
  • Logical flow: Prerequisites → Data Model → Integration → Testing
  • Comprehensive coverage: Covers all necessary components (blueprints, webhooks, actions, automations)
  • Practical approach: Uses realistic HiBob API structure and Port patterns

CONTRIBUTING.md Compliance

Strengths

  • Proper header capitalization: "Ingest and map HiBob users to Port user accounts" ✓
  • Second-person pronouns: Uses "you" and "your" appropriately ✓
  • We language in guides: Uses "We will leverage..." and "Let's test it" ✓
  • Code blocks: All have proper showLineNumbers
  • Full path links: All links use full paths ✓
  • Collapsible sections: Proper use of <details> with bold titles ✓
  • Admonitions: Good use of :::info with descriptive titles ✓
  • Active voice: "Port connects..." style used throughout ✓

⚠️ Areas Needing Attention

  1. Headers inside tabs (Line 30):

    <h3> Create the HiBob User blueprint</h3>

    Compliant: Correctly uses <h3> instead of ### inside sections

  2. Missing screenshots/GIFs:

    • The guide would benefit from screenshots of the Port UI steps
    • Consider adding GIFs for complex multi-step processes
    • Recommendation: Add screenshots for blueprint creation, webhook setup, and testing steps
  3. Link validation needed:

    • Links reference Port docs and HiBob API docs
    • All internal Port links use correct full paths
    • External HiBob links should be verified for accuracy

🔧 Technical Accuracy

  • JSON schemas: Well-structured and comprehensive
  • API endpoints: Correct HiBob API usage
  • Port mapping: Proper use of JQ expressions and Port blueprint structure
  • Authentication: Correct HiBob service user authentication pattern

📝 Writing Style

  • Tone: Professional and instructional ✓
  • Clarity: Steps are clear and actionable ✓
  • Completeness: Includes troubleshooting context and expected outcomes ✓
  • Search optimization: Good use of relevant keywords ✓

Code Changes Review

src/components/guides-section/consts.js

  • Proper placement: Added to end of array as expected
  • Correct structure: Follows existing pattern perfectly
  • Appropriate tags: Uses relevant tags: "SDLC","Actions", "Automations", "Webhook"
  • Logo selection: Webhook logo is appropriate for the integration type
  • URL path: Matches the file location correctly

🎯 Recommendations for Enhancement

  1. Add Visual Aids:

    # Add screenshots for key steps
    <img src='/img/guides/hibob/blueprint-creation.png' width='75%' border='1px' />
  2. Include Troubleshooting Section:
    Consider adding a troubleshooting section for common issues like:

    • Authentication failures
    • Mapping errors
    • Webhook connection issues
  3. Add Expected Outcomes:
    After major steps, add expected results:

    **Expected Result**: You should see 15 HiBob users created in your catalog with proper relationships established.

🚀 Final Verdict

✅ APPROVED - This PR meets the documentation standards and provides valuable integration guidance. The guide is well-structured, technically accurate, and follows the established patterns.

Minor Suggestions: Consider adding screenshots and a troubleshooting section in a follow-up PR to enhance user experience.


@github-actions github-actions bot deleted a comment from claude bot Aug 11, 2025
@github-actions github-actions bot deleted a comment from claude bot Aug 12, 2025
…r' of github.com:port-labs/port-docs into PORTN-3057-create-a-guide-to-map-hibob-user-to-port-user
@github-actions github-actions bot deleted a comment from claude bot Aug 12, 2025
Copy link

claude bot commented Aug 12, 2025

Claude finished @kodjomiles's task —— View job


PR Review: HiBob Users to Port Accounts Guide

Todo List:

  • Read CONTRIBUTING.md to understand review criteria
  • Review the new guide file (map-hibob-users-to-port-accounts.md)
  • Review the const.js modifications
  • Check for compliance with documentation standards
  • Provide detailed feedback

Overall Assessment

This PR successfully adds a comprehensive guide for integrating HiBob users with Port accounts. The implementation follows most documentation standards from CONTRIBUTING.md with some excellent practices demonstrated.

📋 Detailed Review

Content Quality & Structure

  • Clear objective: Well-defined purpose and expected outcomes (lines 8-16)
  • Logical flow: Prerequisites → Data Model → Integration → Testing
  • Comprehensive coverage: Covers all necessary components (blueprints, webhooks, actions, automations)
  • Practical approach: Uses realistic HiBob API structure and Port patterns

CONTRIBUTING.md Compliance Analysis

Excellent Adherence

  1. Header capitalization (line 6): ✅ "Ingest and map HiBob users to Port user accounts" - follows lowercase rule
  2. Second-person pronouns: ✅ Uses "you" and "your" appropriately throughout
  3. "We" language in guides (line 10): ✅ "We will leverage..." follows guide conventions
  4. Code blocks: ✅ All use proper showLineNumbers (lines 43, 120, 138, etc.)
  5. Full path links (lines 21, 32, 109): ✅ All internal links use full paths
  6. Collapsible sections: ✅ Perfect use of <details> with bold titles (lines 40, 117, 135)
  7. Admonitions: ✅ Excellent use of :::info with descriptive titles (lines 151, 170, 238)
  8. Active voice (line 8): ✅ "Port connects..." style used throughout
  9. Headers inside tabs: ✅ Correctly uses <h3> instead of ### (line 30)

🔧 Technical Accuracy

  • JSON schemas: Well-structured and comprehensive (lines 43-99)
  • API endpoints: Correct HiBob API usage and authentication patterns (lines 282, 358)
  • Port mapping: Proper use of JQ expressions and Port blueprint structure (lines 196-232)
  • Webhook configuration: Comprehensive filtering and entity mapping

📝 Writing Style Excellence

  • Tone: Professional and instructional ✅
  • Clarity: Steps are clear and actionable with numbered lists ✅
  • Completeness: Includes troubleshooting context (lines 170-172, 238-240)
  • Search optimization: Good use of relevant keywords ✅

Code Changes Review

src/components/guides-section/consts.js (lines 1339-1344)

  • Proper placement: Added correctly to the array
  • Consistent structure: Follows existing pattern perfectly
  • Appropriate tags: Uses relevant tags: "SDLC","Actions", "Automations", "Webhook"
  • Logo selection: Webhook logo is appropriate for the integration type
  • URL path: Matches the file location correctly

🎯 Areas for Enhancement

1. Visual Aids (Recommended)

The guide would benefit from screenshots for key UI steps:

# Consider adding screenshots for:
- Blueprint creation in Port UI
- Webhook setup interface  
- Self-service action configuration
- Testing results in audit logs

2. Error Handling Documentation

While the guide mentions authentication and basic troubleshooting, consider adding:

  • Common API error responses and solutions
  • Webhook payload validation failures
  • Mapping expression debugging tips

3. Security Best Practices

The guide correctly handles:

  • ✅ Base64 encoding explanation (lines 166-168)
  • ✅ Service user permissions (lines 22-24, 171)
  • ✅ Secret storage in Port (lines 155-173)

🚀 Strengths Highlighted

  1. Comprehensive Integration: Covers the complete workflow from data model to testing
  2. Automation-First Approach: Intelligent use of automations for real-time sync (lines 524-583)
  3. User Experience: Clear step-by-step instructions with expandable code sections
  4. Maintainability: Well-structured JSON configurations that are easy to modify
  5. Documentation Standards: Excellent adherence to Port's documentation guidelines

🏆 Final Verdict

✅ APPROVED - This PR demonstrates excellent technical documentation practices and provides significant value to users implementing HiBob integration with Port.

Key Achievements:

  • Perfect compliance with CONTRIBUTING.md standards
  • Comprehensive technical implementation
  • Clear, actionable instructions
  • Proper security considerations
  • Excellent use of Port's documentation patterns

Recommendation: Merge as-is. Consider adding screenshots in a follow-up PR to enhance user experience further.


Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant