Skip to content

Conversation

honeyranjan1
Copy link

The second code improves upon the first by accurately determining whether a number is a triangle number using a mathematically precise formula. The first code used an approximation method, which could lead to incorrect results. Additionally, the second version fixes a critical issue by returning -1 for non-triangle numbers instead of 0, which is itself a valid triangle number. These changes ensure correct output for all test cases.

Constant Name and Value Changed

const int NoTriangle = 0; → const int NotTriangle = -1;

Triangle Check Logic Modified

Old: n = sqrt(2 * x); → Checks if n(n+1)/2 == x

New: Solves using n = (-1 + sqrt(1 + 8x)) / 2 with full discriminant check

Return Value on Invalid Triangle

Old: Returns NoTriangle (0) if not a triangle

New: Returns NotTriangle (-1) if not a triangle

Condition in main() Updated

Old: if (getTriangle(sum) != NoTriangle)

New: if (getTriangle(sum) != NotTriangle)

Mathematical Accuracy

Old Code: Uses approximation (sqrt)

New Code: Uses exact formula with perfect square and integer check
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant